[guardian-dev] Hi, i' new

arrase arrase at gmail.com
Mon Nov 14 19:32:12 EST 2016

I have reviewed the application of:


I have it installed and I see that when using its own Tor daemon it
conflicts with Orbor and I think that is a problem.

The people of briarproject could configure their application not to
conflict with Orbot but I do not think that is a solution in the long term
if it is intended that more applications use self-managed hidden services
with ability to back up the service so as not to lose it between device
changes .

In my opinion extend the Orbot api for hidden services to open these to the
development of applications that use them intensively would be a great idea.

2016-11-14 15:29 GMT+01:00 arrase <arrase at gmail.com>:

> 2016-11-14 14:53 GMT+01:00 Nathan of Guardian <nathan at guardianproject.info
> >:
>> I'm happy to improve the hidden service API that Orbot offers to make it
>> work for you. It is trivial for us to add support for requesting a
>> completely new hidden service.
> In general terms and in my modest opinion I believe that extending the
> support of hidden services as you say is a good way to take Orbot to the
> next level.
> Personally and I'm not an expert, I think the option of including Tor
> built in an application is not the best option for several reasons, i think
> Orbot should be the standard for building Tor applications on phones but
> needs to be more flexible with the configuration of hidden services.
> I believe in the benefits of hidden services, for me it is the best Tor
> has :) and I think they are a great vector to popularize Tor on mobile
> devices.
> Orbot can also support the temporary hidden service capability in tor,
>> where you generate and provide the .onion key yourself. The issue is
>> that you have to do that each time tor is restarted.
>  I have not used ephemeral services since for now I have not found them
> practical use so I do not know much about them, just that they exist and
> how they are configured, i'm sorry.
> As Hans said, Briar is already doing quite a bit with HS management with
>> their built in Tor, but I do hope many apps will support HS without
>> building in tor as well.
>> You can also see what the Thali Project from Microsoft did here:
>> http://thaliproject.org/ThaliAndTorOnionProxy/
>   As Hans said the Briar project seems to be very similar to my idea,
> maybe I can help instead of duplicating efforts, thanks for the clue.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.mayfirst.org/pipermail/guardian-dev/attachments/20161115/610a7c02/attachment.html>

More information about the guardian-dev mailing list